
Photo: RDNE Stock project via Pexels
It is three in the morning and a patient who was calm at handover is pulling at the tubing across her chest. A nurse who has been taught only that "unsafe behavior needs a restraint" sees a problem that can be solved with a device. A nurse who has been taught the rest of the subject sees a symptom: a full bladder, pain nobody asked about, a hearing aid left in a drawer, a delirium that began at dusk. The first nurse reaches for equipment. The second reaches for a question.
That shift from device to question is the heart of restraint reduction, which regulators, professional bodies and hospital quality programs have promoted for decades. Federal rules make restraint a last resort, nursing's professional association has called for a restraint-free culture, and the evidence on delirium shows why reaching for the cause works better than reaching for a strap.
This article explains what the standards require, what the alternatives programs teach, and how nurses are assessed on the competency. It describes principles and regulations. It is not guidance for any patient in front of you, and your facility's policy, state law and the responsible clinician's orders govern what happens in real care.
The central text is the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) condition of participation on patients' rights for hospitals, 42 CFR 482.13(e). It states that restraint or seclusion may be imposed only to ensure the immediate physical safety of the patient, a staff member or others, and that it must be discontinued at the earliest possible time. It requires that the type of restraint used be the least restrictive that will be effective, and the regulation and its interpretive guidance treat restraint as appropriate only when less restrictive interventions have been determined to be ineffective.
Several other provisions matter for a learner. An order for restraint or seclusion may never be a standing or as-needed order. Staff with direct patient contact must have ongoing education and training in the proper and safe use of restraint and in alternatives to it. Particular rules apply to restraint used for violent or self-destructive behavior, including time-limited orders and a face-to-face evaluation soon after the intervention begins, and facilities must report certain deaths. The Joint Commission's accreditation standards also address restraint and seclusion. The exact intervals and who may order are set by the regulation, state law and facility policy, which is why this article does not list them: a learner should read them in the source.
The American Nurses Association (ANA) addressed the subject in a 2020 position statement, The Ethical Use of Restraints: Balancing Dual Nursing Duties of Patient Safety and Personal Safety, which supersedes its 2012 statement on reducing patient restraint and seclusion. It says nurses have a duty to promote a restraint-free culture, recommends alternatives and less restrictive measures, and also recognizes that nurses must balance patient safety with their own safety when violence is a risk. The Joint Commission has long treated restraint deaths as a patient safety concern: it issued Sentinel Event Alert issue 8, Preventing Restraint Deaths, in November 1998, which is part of why the regulatory framework looks as it does.
In geriatric care, the American Geriatrics Society's Choosing Wisely recommendations advise against using physical restraints to manage behavioral symptoms of hospitalized older adults with delirium. The reasoning, as the Society states it, is that restraints have little proven benefit in these situations, can cause serious injury, and may increase agitation. In mental health settings, the National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors published the Six Core Strategies to Reduce the Use of Seclusion and Restraint, developed by Kevin Huckshorn, which shifts the focus to leadership, data, workforce development, use of prevention tools, involving people with lived experience, and debriefing after every event.
Printable study guide
Nurse Journal: 14 Days of Reflection
A sixteen-page printable reflection journal from Wahero Health Institute that helps you identify areas for improvement. Restraint decisions are among the situations nurses most often want to think through afterward, and a written reflection is a safe place to do it.
Nurse Journal: 14 Days of Reflection, $12.99
Pay by Cash App, PayPal or Zelle at checkout; the download link is emailed once the payment is confirmed, usually the same day. Study material only: it does not replace the Board's requirements, your employer's policies or the judgment of a licensed clinician.
A debrief is prevention, not paperwork. Reviewing every event, including the ones that ended well, is how a unit learns which shift, which routine or which unmet need keeps producing the same crisis.
The strongest evidence for alternatives is not about restraint at all; it is about delirium, a common setting in which older patients are restrained. Inouye and colleagues' 1999 trial in the New England Journal of Medicine tested the Hospital Elder Life Program, in which an interdisciplinary team and trained volunteers targeted six risk factors: cognitive impairment, sleep deprivation, immobility, visual impairment, hearing impairment and dehydration. In this matched-comparison study of 852 patients aged 70 or older, delirium developed in 9.9 percent of the intervention group and 15.0 percent of the usual-care group, and total days of delirium were lower (105 against 161). The program has since been widely adopted and studied.
The finding translates into a teaching principle. If a nurse can prevent or shorten the delirium, the situation that tempts staff toward restraint never fully forms. That is why alternatives training spends so much time on routine, orientation, sleep, mobility, sensory aids, hydration and toileting rather than on techniques of containment, and why an alternatives program is judged by how rarely restraint is needed, not by how skillfully it is applied.
Ask what the behavior is telling you. In most alternatives curricula the first step is a cause, not a response. A patient who tries to leave, pull at a line or climb out of bed is communicating a need, a fear or a confusion, and the assessment comes before any decision about equipment.
Restraint competency is usually checked through knowledge questions and a scenario, often with a standardized patient or a manikin and a staged agitated presentation. Knowledge items test the regulation: what counts as a restraint, why the order cannot be as needed, what must be documented, who must be involved, and why the intervention must end as early as possible. The scenario tests the order of thinking: whether the learner identifies possible causes before deciding anything, tries and records less restrictive responses, speaks calmly and respectfully to the patient, calls the appropriate team under facility policy, and documents.
Debriefing is a competency in its own right. After an event, many programs expect a review with the team and, where appropriate, with the patient: what happened, what could have been done earlier, and what the patient experienced. That practice comes from restraint-reduction frameworks such as the Six Core Strategies, and it is also how institutions find the patterns, such as a particular shift or a particular unit, that lead to repeat events. If the experience troubles you afterwards, our article on moral distress in nursing describes why that response is common and what programs do about it.
Documentation completes the picture. Facility policies generally expect the record to show what was observed, what was tried first, who was notified, the order, the monitoring, and the end of the intervention. Our articles on fall risk assessment tools and clinical handover communication cover related assessment and communication skills that these scenarios draw on.
The regulatory framing is, at root, about rights: the rule appears under patients' rights because freedom of movement is a right that can be limited only for narrow reasons and for as short a time as possible. Nurses are not only implementers of that framework; they are often the first person to notice that a restraint is no longer needed, or never was. A nurse who can articulate the least-restrictive standard in plain terms can speak up in a huddle, ask for a review, and help the patient and family understand why a decision was made. Speaking up is a skill, and the facility's chain of command and its patient safety channels are where it is exercised.
Educational use. This article is learning material for nurses and nursing students. It is not clinical advice, and it does not replace your employer's policies, your facility's protocols, or the judgement of a licensed clinician. Always follow the standards and procedures in force where you practise.
What counts as a restraint under the federal rules? Under the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services rule on patients' rights for hospitals, 42 CFR 482.13(e), a restraint includes a physical or mechanical method that immobilizes a patient or reduces their ability to move freely, and a drug used as a restriction to manage behavior rather than as standard treatment. Whether a device is a restraint can depend on its purpose and effect, so read your facility policy and the regulation.
Can a restraint order be written "as needed"? No. The federal rule states that an order for restraint or seclusion must never be written as a standing order or on an as-needed basis. The rule also limits use to ensuring the immediate physical safety of the patient, staff or others, and requires that it be discontinued at the earliest possible time.
Do restraints prevent harm in older hospitalized patients? The American Geriatrics Society's Choosing Wisely recommendation advises against using physical restraints to manage behavioral symptoms of hospitalized older adults with delirium. Restraint has its own injury risks, which is why prevention of delirium and its triggers is the focus of alternatives programs.
What is the Hospital Elder Life Program? It is a multicomponent delirium-prevention program described by Inouye and colleagues in the New England Journal of Medicine in 1999. In that study, an interdisciplinary team targeting risk factors such as cognitive impairment, sleep deprivation, immobility, sensory impairment and dehydration lowered the initial occurrence of delirium and the total days of delirium compared with usual care.
Does this article tell me what to do with an agitated patient? No. It describes the standards and how the competency is taught and assessed. What to do for a particular patient depends on the assessment, the orders and your facility's policy, and a nurse should involve the responsible clinician and the facility's team rather than rely on any article.
Reducing restraint depends on noticing early and escalating well. Wahero Health Institute delivers in-person training on clinical judgment and independent practice across Texas, assessed under observation. See the Building Skills for Clinical Autonomy course or browse the full catalog.
Educational content only
This material is published by Wahero Health Institute for professional education and is not individual medical advice, a care protocol, or a substitute for clinical judgment. Always follow your facility's policies, your state's nurse practice act, and your own scope of practice, and confirm medication doses against a current authoritative reference before administration. See our Terms of Use.