📧 info@waherohealthinstitute.com•📞 (832) 490-4024 Mobile clinical education for your facility

Psychological Safety in Simulation: Why Learners Must Be Allowed to Fail

A nurse in blue scrubs gestures as she explains her thinking to a colleague across a draped table in a bright clinical teaching room

A new graduate stands at the bedside of a simulated patient whose oxygen saturation has been drifting down for two minutes. She has noticed. She knows she should call for help. She does not, because the last time she voiced a worry in front of a room of colleagues she was wrong, and someone laughed. The scenario runs out, the patient deteriorates, and in the debrief she says she "did not see it." That is not true, and nobody in the room learns the real lesson.

That moment is a failure of psychological safety, not of knowledge. It is also a preview: a nurse who has learned to stay silent when unsure will carry that habit onto a unit, where the patient is real. Simulation is one of the few places in nursing education where silence can be noticed, discussed and unlearned before it costs anyone anything.

This article explains what psychological safety means, why simulation only works when learners are allowed to fail, how programs build that safety, what destroys it, and why it is not the same as low standards. Our earlier article on why debriefing matters more than the scenario covers safety inside the debrief itself; this one looks at the whole experience and at the decisions facilities and educators make around it.

What psychological safety means, and what it does not

The term comes from organizational research. Amy Edmondson of Harvard Business School, in a 1999 study of work teams, defined team psychological safety as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. The interpersonal risks are ordinary ones: asking a question that might sound basic, admitting you are unsure, pointing out a problem, or owning a mistake. Where people believe those acts will not be punished, they do them, and teams learn. Where they believe otherwise, problems stay hidden.

Three misunderstandings are worth clearing up early. It is not comfort: a safe session can still be stressful. It is not niceness: a warm facilitator can still run a room where nobody dares to be wrong. And it is not low standards. In her later writing, Edmondson pairs psychological safety with a second dimension, the level of accountability or motivation for demanding goals. High safety with low accountability produces a comfortable room where little is learned. High accountability with low safety produces anxiety. Learning happens where both are high.

Two by two grid adapted from Edmondson: psychological safety on the horizontal axis and accountability for demanding standards on the vertical axis. Low safety and low accountability is the apathy zone, high safety and low accountability is the comfort zone, low safety and high accountability is the anxiety zone, and high safety with high accountability is the learning zone. Anxiety zone Learning zone Apathy zone Comfort zone High standard, mistakes hidden High standard, mistakes discussed Little asked, little offered Pleasant, little stretch Psychological safety: low to high Accountability: low to high
Where simulation should operate Where many graded sessions drift
Safety and standards are separate dimensions, and simulation needs both. Conceptual framework adapted from Amy Edmondson's work on psychological safety and learning; not measured data.

Why failure is a design feature, not a side effect

On a unit, a nurse who makes a poor decision is usually rescued by a colleague, a protocol or a provider before the consequence unfolds. That protects patients, but nurses rarely see where their reasoning would have led. Simulation removes the rescue. A learner can follow a wrong decision to its end, watch the patient's condition change, and then examine every step in the debrief. Few other teaching methods offer that.

There is also evidence from outside healthcare that learning from errors transfers well. Nina Keith and Michael Frese published a meta-analysis in the Journal of Applied Psychology in 2008 comparing error management training, in which trainees are encouraged to make errors and learn from them, with training designed to avoid errors. Error management training produced better outcomes overall, and the advantage was larger when trainees later faced tasks that differed from the ones they had practiced. Nursing is full of situations that differ from the textbook.

None of this works if learners are protecting themselves. A learner managing how she looks will choose the familiar action, keep her thinking to herself, and explain away her decisions in the debrief. The scenario then tests self-presentation rather than clinical judgment.

Allowed to fail means allowed to be seen failing. The point of simulation is not to avoid mistakes but to make them visible, so they can be understood while the patient is a manikin. A learner who hides an error has wasted the one place where errors are free.

How safety is built before the scenario starts

Psychological safety is not announced; it is constructed. The INACSL Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice, first published under that name in 2021 and revised since, include a standard on prebriefing whose stated purpose includes establishing a psychologically safe learning environment. It divides the prebrief into preparation, so learners arrive with the knowledge the scenario assumes, and briefing, which sets out the ground rules for the session.

Jenny Rudolph, Daniel Raemer and Robert Simon of the Center for Medical Simulation described the result as a "safe container" for learning, in a 2014 paper in the journal Simulation in Healthcare. Their elements are practical. Clarify the objectives and what is expected of learners. Agree a fiction contract: the educators commit to making the scenario as realistic as they can and being honest about what is not, and learners commit to engaging as if it were real. Attend to logistics so that nobody is ambushed by the environment. And state, then demonstrate, respect for the learners. The same center's Basic Assumption puts that respect into one sentence: everyone participating is intelligent, capable, cares about doing their best and wants to improve.

A prebrief that builds safety usually covers the following:

Our first-timer's walkthrough of what happens in a simulation lab shows how this looks from the learner's side of the room.

The line that must never blur: practice versus judgment

The fastest way to destroy psychological safety is to call a session practice and then use it to judge people. Learners notice, and afterwards they treat every simulation as a test. The INACSL standards distinguish formative evaluation, which supports development, from summative and high-stakes evaluation, which produce a decision about the learner. Both are legitimate. What is not legitimate is leaving the learner unsure which one is happening.

For facilities, this has a concrete implication. If a session is part of a competency validation program, say so in advance, define what is being observed, and use a clear tool. If a session is practice, keep its records out of performance management. The INACSL standard on professional integrity expects confidentiality of performances according to institutional policy, which means the policy has to exist and has to be followed when it is inconvenient.

What breaks psychological safety in practice

Most programs do not set out to make learners afraid. Safety erodes through habits that seem harmless to the people running the session. The comparison below lists patterns that come up often in simulation education, alongside what tends to replace them in programs that protect safety well.

Comparison of habits that break psychological safety with habits that build it: an unstated purpose versus a stated purpose, trick scenarios versus challenge tied to objectives, laughing at errors versus curiosity about reasoning, recordings shared casually versus recordings governed by policy, a silent manager in the room versus declared roles, and moving on after a distressing event versus acknowledging it Breaks safety Builds safety Purpose left unstated Formative or summative, said up front Trick scenarios to catch people out Hard scenarios tied to objectives Laughter or sighs at errors Curiosity about the reasoning Recordings shared informally Recordings governed by policy A silent manager watching Every observer's role declared Moving on after distress Acknowledging it before analysis
Six common patterns and their alternatives. A conceptual summary drawn from the INACSL standards and the safe container literature, not measured data.

Two of these deserve a closer look. The first is the trick scenario. Scenarios can legitimately include surprises such as a sudden change in the patient. But a scenario built to catch learners out, with information withheld that no nurse could reasonably obtain, teaches only that the facilitator cannot be trusted. Every hard moment in a scenario should map to an objective the learners were told about.

The second is emotional distress. Scenarios involving a patient death, an angry family member or a missed deterioration can affect learners more than facilitators expect, particularly learners who have lived through something similar. A debrief that goes straight to analysis without acknowledging that reaction tells the group that feelings are not welcome, and the analysis suffers for it. New nurses in particular, as our article on imposter syndrome explains, tend to read one bad moment as proof they do not belong.

Allowed to fail does not mean allowed to coast

Some clinicians worry that psychological safety means shielding learners from honest feedback. The opposite is true. In a safe session the feedback can be more direct, because the learner trusts that it is about the decision rather than about her. The phrase many educators use is that the room is safe to fail, not safe from feedback.

In practice that means the scenario is genuinely demanding, the facilitator names the gap between what happened and what the objective required, and the learner is expected to explain and own her reasoning. The facilitator does not turn that gap into a judgment of the learner's worth. A learner who hears "your assessment missed the change in breathing; talk me through what you were focused on at that moment" is being held to a high standard. A learner who hears "you would have killed that patient" is being shamed, and she will learn to hide the next mistake rather than examine it.

High challenge, high support. The best simulation sessions are uncomfortable in a specific and productive way. The discomfort comes from the problem, never from the people in the room.

Why facility leaders should care

For a facility, this is not a teaching nicety. The norms staff experience in training are the norms they take back to the unit. A nurse who has raised a concern in simulation and seen it welcomed is more likely to raise one on a night shift.

AHRQ's TeamSTEPPS program teaches structured tools for raising concerns, such as the CUS words (I am concerned, I am uncomfortable, this is a safety issue), because speaking up is hard in hierarchical teams. Simulation is the natural place to practice them, but only if the session rewards their use. Three decisions are within a leader's control:

Key takeaways

Frequently asked questions

What is psychological safety in simulation? It is the shared belief among learners that they can speak up, ask questions, admit uncertainty and make mistakes without being humiliated or punished. Amy Edmondson defined psychological safety in teams as a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk taking. In simulation it is built in the prebrief and protected through the scenario and debrief.

Does psychological safety mean simulation should be easy? No. A psychologically safe session can be very challenging. Safety refers to how mistakes are treated, not to how hard the scenario is. The aim is a session where the standard is high and the cost of falling short is learning rather than embarrassment.

Can a graded simulation still be psychologically safe? It can be fair and respectful, but learners will reasonably take fewer risks when a grade is at stake. That is why the INACSL standards expect the purpose of a session, formative or summative, to be stated in advance. The problem is not grading itself; it is calling a session a safe space for practice and then using it to judge.

Should managers watch staff in simulation sessions? It depends on the purpose. In formative practice sessions, a manager in the room can quietly change what staff are willing to say, so many programs keep them out or give them a defined role. If a session validates competency, staff should be told beforehand who will see the results and how they will be used.

What should a learner do if a debrief feels unsafe? Raise it, ideally with the facilitator after the session or with the program lead. Programs working to the INACSL standards are expected to maintain a safe learning environment and to keep performances confidential according to their policies. Feedback about how a session felt is useful to the people running it.

Simulation where learners can afford to be wrong

Wahero Health Institute runs simulation for nursing students, new graduates and working nurses with a structured prebrief, a clear statement of purpose and a facilitated debrief in every session, and brings the same approach on site to hospitals, nursing programs and long-term care facilities across Texas. See how our sessions run on the simulation lab page, review our services for facilities, or talk to us about building psychologically safe simulation into your orientation and competency program.

Schedule Training Explore the Simulation Lab

Educational content only

This material is published by Wahero Health Institute for professional education and is not individual medical advice, a care protocol, or a substitute for clinical judgment. Always follow your facility's policies, your state's nurse practice act, and your own scope of practice, and confirm medication doses against a current authoritative reference before administration. See our Terms of Use.