Three weeks into her first job, a new nurse asks a question at the nurses' station. The senior nurse sighs, says "Didn't they teach you that in school?" and turns back to her screen. Later the same nurse finds that report on a shared patient was given without her. At the end of the shift nobody offers help with her late admission, though two colleagues are charting at the next desk. No single moment is something she could write up. By week six, she has stopped asking questions.
That last sentence is the one that matters for patients. Our earlier article on where "nurses eat their young" came from and what it costs explains the history and the research. This article is the field guide: how to tell incivility from bullying from honest feedback, what it looks like on a real unit, what a new nurse can say and write down, where to take it, and what managers can do from the first day of orientation.
The guidance here is about behavior and workplace culture. It is not legal advice; if you think you are facing discrimination or retaliation, your HR department and an employment attorney are the right places to ask.
The American Nurses Association's 2015 position statement, Incivility, Bullying, and Workplace Violence, gives the profession a shared vocabulary. Using it precisely matters, because each problem calls for a different response.
The ANA's position is that nurses and their employers share an ethical and legal responsibility to create a culture of respect free of all three. That is a deliberate choice: it does not leave the problem with managers alone, and it does not leave it with the person on the receiving end.
Some of it is loud and easy to name. Public criticism in front of patients or families. Raised voices. Belittling remarks about your school, your age, your accent or how long you have been a nurse. Questions answered with contempt rather than information.
Most of it is quiet, and that is why it lasts. Watch for:
Each of these has an innocent explanation available, which is exactly what makes them hard to raise. The answer is not to argue about any single moment. It is to see the pattern, and to write it down.
New nurses receive a lot of correction, and they should: it is how practice gets safe. Not every hard conversation is bullying, and treating real feedback as an attack will cost you the learning you need. Ask five questions about the behavior:
The goal in the moment is not to win. It is to keep patient care moving, to name the behavior calmly, and to leave yourself something to raise later. Short, prepared phrases work far better than anything you invent while your heart is racing:
Rehearsing phrases like these in advance is the basis of cognitive rehearsal, which our article on the origins of the phrase explains in detail. One rule overrides everything else: never let incivility stop you getting an answer about patient safety. If the person you would normally ask is the problem, ask the charge nurse, another experienced nurse or the provider, and use a clear structure such as SBAR so the question cannot be brushed aside.
A manager can act on a pattern. A manager can do very little with "she is always mean to me." Start a private log as soon as you suspect something is more than one bad day, and keep it consistently.
For each entry, record the date, time and place; the exact words or actions, quoted where you can; who else was present; and any effect on patient care, such as a delayed medication or a missed piece of information. Keep the log on a personal device or in a notebook, never in the patient record, and leave patient names and identifiers out of it entirely. Write facts rather than feelings: "Asked about bed 7's pain medication timing; was told 'figure it out yourself' in front of the patient's daughter" is far stronger than "she was horrible again."
Start with the person closest to the problem who has the power to change it: your preceptor or the unit educator during orientation, then the charge nurse or your manager. If the person bullying you is your manager, go to their director or to human resources. Bring your log, say what you would like to happen, and ask what the next step will be and when.
Two situations go beyond unit culture. If the behavior targets your race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability or another protected characteristic, it may be unlawful harassment under federal law enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission; report it to HR in writing. If there are threats or physical harm, report it at once. Texas now requires covered hospitals, nursing facilities, home health agencies and ambulatory surgical centers to maintain a written workplace violence prevention policy and plan under Chapter 331 of the Health and Safety Code, passed as Senate Bill 240 in 2023, and that process is the right route.
Look after yourself while it is being resolved. Most employers fund a free, confidential Employee Assistance Program, and talking to someone outside the unit helps you keep perspective. If the experience is affecting your sleep, mood or health, talk to your doctor.
The Joint Commission has treated behavior that undermines a culture of safety as a leadership responsibility since its 2008 Sentinel Event Alert on the subject, and its leadership standards expect a code of conduct and a process for managing unacceptable behavior. A policy on a shelf is not that process. These steps make it real:
Most incivility happens in front of other nurses, and the ANA's position is clear that the obligation to stop it is not limited to managers. A bystander does not need to make a speech. "I can help with that admission" breaks an exclusion. "Let's talk about it after report" moves a public correction out of public view. A quiet "that was not okay, are you all right?" afterward tells a new nurse she is not imagining things, and that is often what keeps her in the profession.
What is the difference between incivility and bullying in nursing? The American Nurses Association defines incivility as one or more rude, discourteous or disrespectful actions that may or may not have a negative intent behind them, and bullying as repeated, unwanted harmful actions intended to humiliate, offend and cause distress. The practical difference is repetition and intent: a single eye roll is incivility, while a sustained campaign aimed at one nurse is bullying.
Should I report a senior nurse who is rude to me? A single rude moment is often best addressed directly and privately, if you feel safe doing so. A pattern should be reported. Keep dated notes of what was said or done, who saw it and how it affected patient care, then take them to your preceptor, charge nurse or manager. A pattern written down is something a manager can act on; a general impression is not.
What if the person bullying me is my preceptor? Go to your unit's nurse educator or your manager, because they assign preceptors and can change the pairing. Bring specific examples and keep the focus on your learning and patient safety. Asking for a different preceptor is a legitimate request, and a good orientation program has a route for it.
Is bullying at work illegal? Not all workplace bullying is unlawful, but some of it is. Harassment based on a protected characteristic such as race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age or disability can violate federal law enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and threats or physical violence fall under your facility's workplace violence policy, which Texas facilities covered by Chapter 331 of the Health and Safety Code must have. Report through HR, and seek independent advice if you need it.
What can a nurse manager do about incivility on day one? State the standard out loud at every orientation, name the behaviors that are not acceptable, including the covert ones, and say exactly how new nurses can raise a concern. Then respond to the first report within days, not months. The Joint Commission expects leaders to maintain a code of conduct and a process for managing behavior that undermines a culture of safety.
The words that defuse an uncivil moment are hard to find under pressure and easy to find once rehearsed. Wahero's New Graduate Transition to Practice course rehearses asking for help, handover and speaking up, and our Building Clinical Autonomy course builds the confidence that makes a new nurse harder to push aside. For facilities, we bring civility and preceptor training to your unit; schedule a conversation.
Educational content only
This material is published by Wahero Health Institute for professional education and is not individual medical advice, a care protocol, or a substitute for clinical judgment. Always follow your facility's policies, your state's nurse practice act, and your own scope of practice, and confirm medication doses against a current authoritative reference before administration. See our Terms of Use.